Former mining executive Tim Sullivan plays a controversial role in Wisconsin legislature deliberations 12.12.12
Bill Lueders, Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism on Wednesday 12/12/2012 11:43 am
Sullivan says he has no stock in Bucyrus, his former company, or any other mining concern.
On Nov. 29, Tim Sullivan appeared before Wisconsin's Senate Select Committee on Mining and presented a report critiquing the state's mining laws. The report was commissioned by the Wisconsin Mining Association, a trade group for which he serves as chairman.
Sullivan urged the state (PDF) to "unleash the economic power of Wisconsin's rich mineral deposits for our citizens." He said the mining bill that narrowly failed to pass the state Senate earlier this year "needs improving," but he offered few details.
Sullivan is the former head of Bucyrus International, a Milwaukee-based manufacturer of mining equipment. In recent weeks, he has emerged as a key player in ongoing efforts to revamp the state's mining laws.
The mining bill in the past legislative session drew more than 8,500 hours of lobbying activity by more than 50 groups. Sullivan's role this time around seems as significant as any of those efforts.
Yet Sullivan is not a lobbyist. He's not registered with the state Government Accountability Board, and he doesn't report how many hours he spends bending official ears on the issue.
Some lawmakers have noted that Sullivan's advice was solicited, not thrust upon them. "It's not so much that Tim Sullivan is lobbying us -- it's more the other way around," says state Sen. Bob Jauch (D-Poplar), the committee's vice chairman.
Jonathan Becker, head of the GAB's ethics division, says that doesn't make any difference: "Even if the Legislature is reaching out for the information, if you provide it, that's lobbying."
But Sullivan chairs the mining association as a volunteer. And the lobby law, Becker confirms, "only applies to people who get paid." So he doesn't have to register.
Now controversy has erupted over the announcement, made soon after his mining committee appearance, that Sullivan was elected to serve on the board of Cliffs Natural Resources, the owner of large iron ore mines in Minnesota and Michigan's Upper Peninsula. The company's board members last year received compensation of between $173,000 and $225,000.
Bob Seitz, a registered lobbyist for Gogebic Taconite, which had and may still have an interest in opening a $1.5 billion iron mine in northern Wisconsin, accuses Sullivan of wanting to make mining more difficult to kneecap the competition.
"A mine in northern Wisconsin would be a direct, lower-cost competitor to Cliffs' mines already in place," Seitz says.
According to Sullivan, federal rules barred revealing his ties with Cliffs earlier. But Seitz says he could and should have refrained from testifying.
"To have someone with a significant financial interest in a competing company not disclose that violates the spirit of the law," Seitz says, speculating that Sullivan's example could allow others to evade the reporting rules. "All you'd have to do is set up a nonprofit and volunteer for it."
Creating a sham organization to evade the lobbying law strikes Becker as "a fiction and a fraud" that would be investigated as such. But just having a financial stake in legislation, as is alleged for Sullivan, does not make anyone a paid lobbyist. "I don't think it violates anything," Becker says.
Sullivan says that he has no stock in Bucyrus, his former company, or any other mining concern, and that his consulting work with various mining interests is all done for free. His role on the Cliffs board, which he'll start in January, will be his only paid gig, and could affect his role with the mining association: "That's a discussion I plan to have with the [WMA] board."
Some allege that Sullivan's openness to changes in the mining bill is at odds with the position of the mining association. Sullivan says that's not true, and mining association board member Jim Wood backs him up.
"The bill can be better," Wood says. "That is the position of WMA and Tim Sullivan." In fact, Wood hopes Sullivan will stay on as chairman of the mining association board.
Bill Lueders (blueders@wisconsinwatch.org) is the Money and Politics Project director at the Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism. The project, a partnership with MapLight, is supported by the Open Society Institute.
The nonprofit and nonpartisan Center collaborates with Wisconsin Public Television, Wisconsin Public Radio, other news media and the UW-Madison School of Journalism and Mass Communication. All works created, published, posted or disseminated by the Center do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of UW-Madison or any of its affiliates.